"I guarantee you 80% will be failures" - Backrooms Producer Warns Hollywood Against Chasing the Trend

The breakout success of Backrooms, a low-budget psychological horror film inspired by a YouTube series, is forcing Hollywood to rethink its long-standing approach to big-budget franchises. As studios rush to replicate the film’s momentum, producer Peter Chernin is warning that chasing trends may not be the answer.

In a recent interview, Chernin argued that the industry’s reaction to Backrooms reflects a deeper issue. Instead of innovating, studios risk falling into the same pattern that has dominated Hollywood for years.

Why Backrooms Became a Box Office Surprise

Backrooms has emerged as one of the most talked-about films of 2026, largely due to its unconventional origins and modest production scale. Directed by YouTube creator Kane Parsons and produced with a reported budget of around $10 million, the film quickly gained traction among younger audiences.

The movie crossed $100 million at the domestic box office in just six days, making it the highest-grossing domestic release in A24’s history. Audience data also showed that 86% of ticket buyers were under the age of 35, highlighting its strong appeal among younger viewers.

The film’s success has been widely attributed to its fresh concept and its roots in internet culture, which helped it resonate with audiences already familiar with the original YouTube content.

Peter Chernin Warns Against “Bandwagon” Thinking

Despite the film’s success, Chernin believes Hollywood is misinterpreting the takeaway. Speaking in the CNBC interview, he cautioned against studios rushing to sign deals with YouTube creators simply to replicate the formula.

“It’s no different than making sequels. It’s jumping on an existing bandwagon,”

Chernin said.

“I guarantee you 80% will be failures. It involves no originality, it involves no innovation.”

Instead, he emphasized that studios should focus on discovering new voices and developing original ideas. For Chernin, the real lesson of Backrooms is not about its platform of origin but about its uniqueness.

“We are consistently looking for what’s new, what’s interesting, and where the world is going,”

he added, pointing to his company’s broader strategy of identifying emerging creative trends.

Franchise Fatigue Driving Audience Behavior

The success of Backrooms comes at a time when Hollywood is facing growing concerns about franchise fatigue. For more than a decade, studios have relied heavily on sequels, reboots, and established intellectual property to drive box office returns.

However, recent performances suggest that audiences may be shifting their preferences. While large-scale franchise films still dominate globally, some high-profile releases have struggled to meet expectations, particularly among younger viewers.

Entertainment analyst Eric Handler noted in the same CNBC report that audiences are increasingly looking for something different.

“Younger people still want to go to the movies, but they’re looking for something a bit different,”

he said. “You don’t need a $250 million movie to get me interested.”

This shift is creating opportunities for smaller, original films to compete in ways that were less common in previous years.

Risk-Taking Could Define Hollywood’s Next Phase

For Chernin, the path forward is clear. He believes studios need to embrace calculated risk rather than avoid it, even if that means stepping away from proven formulas.

“Risk is ultimately the lifeblood of success,”

he said in the interview.

“Hollywood has gotten itself into a mentality where risk is seen as reckless. But risk is the biggest upside in the world.”

The success of Backrooms and similar low-budget hits suggests that audiences are open to new ideas, especially when those ideas feel authentic. As studios evaluate their strategies, the challenge will be balancing financial security with creative innovation.

While it remains to be seen whether Hollywood will shift its approach in the long term, Backrooms has already sparked a conversation that could influence how films are developed in the coming years.